Friday, January 20, 2017

"One Method is Enough"

Apotex Inc v AstraZeneca Canada Inc 2017 FCA 9 Gauthier JA: Pelletier, Scott JJA var’g 2015 FC 322 as amended by 2015 FC 671 Barnes J
            1,292,693 / omeprazole formulation / LOSEC

Barnes J’s holding that the ‘693 patent valid and infringed turned primarily on the facts, as did the FCA affirmation, but the FCA decision shed interesting light on the proper approach to claim construction. That was subject of yesterday’s post. Today's post turns to the FCA's discussion of Biogen v Medeva.

The ‘693 patent pertains to pharmaceutical preparations containing omeprazole. Omeprazole was a known to be useful in treating gastric and duodenal ulcers, but it turned out to be a particularly difficult compound to formulate. It had to be enteric coated to prevent contact with acidic gastric juice, but a conventional enteric coating would react with omeprazole and cause degradation, particularly in storage. The claimed invention solved this problem with an inert subcoating between the omeprazole core and the enteric coating. The disclosure of the 693 patent contemplated that the subcoating would be applied “by conventional coating procedures in a suitable coating pan or in a fluidized bed apparatus using water and/or conventional organic solvents for the coating solution” (p6). In Apotex’s product, in contrast, the putative subcoating was the end product of an in situ chemical reaction that occurs when the enteric coat is applied by Apotex to the pellet cores. The main issue at trial was claim construction: Apotex argued that the claims did not cover a subcoat which forms in situ. Barnes J rejected this argument as a matter of claim construction. (See my post on the FC decision for details.) This holding was affirmed on appeal.

But Apotex had another arrow in its quiver. The ‘693 patent did disclose how to make the claimed invention using conventional coating procedures, but it did not disclose how to make the claimed invention using the in situ process, for the simple reason that the in situ process was developed several years after the patent was issued [80]. Apotex argued that the disclosure was therefore insufficient [80], [81], relying on Teva (VIAGRA) 2012 SCC 60, and Biogen v Medeva [1996] UKHL 18, [1997] RPC 1.

Gauthier JA easily distinguished Teva [80], but the Biogen discussion was more interesting. She distinguished Biogen as follows:

[81] [I]n [Biogen], the reason Lord Hoffman held that the disclosure was insufficient was because of the hybrid nature of the claim and the nature of the invention. In that case, the inventor could not claim a product because the DNA molecule (Dane particle) he had made was not new. He could not claim the process because the process itself was also known; thus, he had to draft the claim to describe the product he was trying to monopolize partly through the way it worked and partly through how it was made.

[82] As indicated above, the 693 Patent is a product claim describing the essential elements of the final structure of the product, thus the nature of the claims in the 693 Patent are not at all similar to the one dealt with in Biogen.

This is not entirely convincing. It is true that the nature of the claims is different, but that in itself does not provide a distinguishing principle. The claim at issue in Biogen was to “A recombinant DNA molecule characterized by a DNA sequence coding for a polypeptide or a fragment thereof displaying HBV antigen specificity. . .” There is no doubt that the disclosure did enable a skilled person to make such a DNA molecule (Biogen, 50), but Lord Hoffmann went on to say (51, my emphasis):

there is more than one way in which the breadth of a claim may exceed the technical contribution to the art embodied in the invention. The patent may claim results which it does not enable, such as making a wide class of products when it enables only one of those products and discloses no principle which would enable others to be made. Or it may claim every way of achieving a result when it enables only one way and it is possible to envisage other ways of achieving that result which make no use of the invention.

It was on this second branch, now known as “Biogen insufficiency,” that the claim failed: “Its excessive breadth is due, not to the inability of the teaching to produce all the promised results, but to the fact that the same results could be produced by different means” (51-52). The defendant Medeva’s method used a different means to produce the same result (52).

With that said, I intend no criticism of Gauthier JA in so distinguishing Biogen, because she was simply adopting Lord Hoffmann’s own subsequent explanation in Lundbeck CA aff’g [2008] EWCA Civ 311 aff’d [2009] UKHL 12, [2009] RPC 13, which she then went on to cite and discuss. In that case Lord Hoffmann said, in a passage quoted by Gauthier JA [86, Gauthier JA's emphasis]:

[27] In an ordinary product claim, the product is the invention. It is sufficiently enabled if the specification and common general knowledge enables the skilled person to make it. One method is enough.

Lord Justice Jacob agreed, in a passage also relied on by Gauthier JA [89]:

[52] I turn to sufficiency. There is a very short answer to this point. The claim is to the (+) enantiomer. That is novel and non-obvious. If one asks the straightforward question "Does the patent enable the skilled man to make it?" the answer is an equally straightforward: "Yes."

Gauthier JA is more than justified in adopting the explanation of Lord Hoffmann’s decision in Biogen provided by Lord Hoffmann himself. But I must say that I don’t find Lord Hoffmann’s distinction based on the form of the claim to be persuasive. The real point of Lord Hoffmann’s Biogen opinion, it seems to me, was to draw a distinction based on the inventive concept, or “technical contribution” as he called it. As stated in the passage quoted above, he was concerned that “the breadth of a claim may exceed the technical contribution to the art embodied in the invention,” and he focused on “the technical contribution to the art which [the inventor] made in 1978 and disclosed in [the patent application]” (51). He concluded by noting that the defendant’s methods “owe nothing” to the invention (52).

But if that is right, then “one method” of enabling the invention is not necessarily enough; it might be, or it might not be, depending on the nature of the inventive concept. Now, on the facts of this particular case, as I understand them, Apotex would have lost even on Biogen insufficiency, because the inventive contribution was not a method of depositing an inert subcoating, but the idea of using an inert subcoating, regardless of the method of deposition. But that conclusion would have required an investigation of the inventive concept, rather than merely an assessment of the nature of the claim.

As I see it, the problem with Biogen insufficiency is that it is not really a sufficiency objection at all, but rather an objection of overbreadth (see eg see Sandvik v Kennametal [2011] EWHC 3311 (Pat) Arnold J at [106]-[124] describing three types of insufficiency in modern UK law as being classical insufficiency, ambiguity and excessive breadth, with the latter corresponding to Biogen insufficiency). As the High Court of Australia perceptively noted in Lockwood (No 1) [2004] HCA 58, [67] the House of Lords' reasoning in Biogen boils down “to the following Voltairean aphorism: ‘Since the fair basis doctrine no longer exists, it is necessary to invent it.’” In Canada, the overbreadth objection is reflected in the principle that an inventor cannot claim more than he has invented: see eg Farbwerke Hoechst AG v. Commissioner of Patents, [1966] ExCR 91, 106; Radio Corp v Raytheon (1957) [1956-60] Ex CR 98, 117; Lovell Manufacturing Co v Beatty Bros (1962), 41 CPR 18, 66 (Ex Ct). The difficulty is that this principle, while very well established, does not have a clear basis in the Act. (The nearest thing is perhaps Rule 84, requiring that the claims be supported by the disclosure, but this is not a particularly clear statement of a prohibition on overbroad claims, and it is in any event discomfiting to have such a fundamental principle found only in the regulations, rather than the Act itself). Nonetheless, in my view, it is probably best to recognize overbreadth as an independent objection, rather than trying to shoehorn it into sufficiency, with the confusing fallout that we have seen from Biogen. So, in my view, the correct approach to sufficiency is indeed that articulated by Gauthier JA, following Lord Hoffmann and Lord Justice Jacob in Lundbeck CA, but I would suggest it should apply regardless of the nature of the claim. This is not to say that Biogen is a dead letter, but rather than the problem it raised should be addressed, in Canadian law at least, as a matter of overbreadth.

Wednesday, January 18, 2017

Claim-First or Disclosure-First in Claim Construction?

Apotex Inc v AstraZeneca Canada Inc 2017 FCA 9 Gauthier JA: Pelletier, Scott JJA var’g 2015 FC 322 as amended by 2015 FC 671 Barnes J
            1,292,693 / omeprazole formulation / LOSEC

As discussed here, Barnes J's decision at first instance, holding that AstraZeneca’s ‘693 patent to be valid and infringed, turned primarily on the facts. Unsurprisingly, the FCA has upheld Barnes J. The FCA decision is nonetheless interesting for its approach to claim construction, particularly in contrast with Locke J’s decision in Mediatube Corp v Bell Canada 2017 FC 6 (blogged here on the costs issue). That aspect of the decision is the focus of this post.

By way over overview, while Apotex raised a number of issues on appeal, the most important related to claim construction [27]. On that issue, Apotex acknowledged that Barnes J had correctly stated the applicable principles, but argued that he had misapplied them [31]. This argument was rejected by Gauthier J, essentially on the basis that it took passages from Barnes J’s decision out of context, and when read as a whole, it was evident that Barnes J had indeed applied the claim construction principles he had articulated (see eg [43]).

The FCA did vary Barnes J’s decision on a limitations period point, which was governed by s 39 of the Federal Courts Act, as this case was decided under the old Act [8]. Section 39 provides that the provincial limitations period applies in respect of any cause of action arising entirely in one province, and a general six year period is otherwise applicable. The FCA held that on the facts, Barnes J had wrongly applied the six year period to all the infringing acts, even though some of them might have arisen entirely in one province [124]. Rather than remanding, the FCA held that the difficult issue of assessing the limitation period applicable in respect of each act could be undertaken in the damages portion of this bifurcated trial [126]. The legal error is of little significance going forward, as s 55.01 of the current Patent Act provides for a general six year limitation period, regardless of where the cause of action arose.

Claim Construction

There is an ongoing debate in Canadian law as to whether recourse to the disclosure as an aid to construing the claims is always permissible, or is permissible only if the claims are ambiguous on their face. The latter position seems to stem from Procter & Gamble Co v Beecham Canada Ltd (1982) 61 CPR(2d) 1 (FCA) at 11, where the FCA reviewed the cases and summarized by saying:

in construing the claims in a patent recourse to the remainder of the specification is (a) permissible only to assist in understanding terms used in the claims; (b) unnecessary where the words of the claim are plain and unambiguous; and (c) improper to vary the scope or ambit of the claims.

(See also Dableh v. Ontario Hydro [1996] 3 FC 751 (FCA), repeating this.) Now, “unnecessary” does not mean “impermissible,” but in Mylan v Eli Lilly (CIALIS) 2016 FCA 119 [39] the FCA took that next step and held that “the judge erred in referring to the specification when construing the claims of the ‘377 patent. The rules of patent construction preclude reference to the specification when the claims are clear, and improper if reference varies the scope of the claims” [sic] (my emphasis). On the other hand, in Whirlpool 2000 SCC 67 Binnie J, for the Court, said that:

"[t]erms must be read in context, and it is therefore unsafe in many instances to conclude that a term is plain and unambiguous without a careful review of the specification". In my view, it was perfectly permissible for the trial judge to look at the rest of the specification, including the drawing, to understand what was meant by the word “vane” in the claims, but not to enlarge or contract the scope of the claim as written and thus understood.

In his recent decision in Mediatube Corp v Bell Canada 2017 FC 6 Locke J had a very careful analysis of this “tension” [37] in the jurisprudence. On that point he quoted and agreed with Zinn J’s discussion in Janssen-Ortho 2010 FC 42, [115-116], [119], including this paragraph:

[115] In my view, the whole of the specification (including the disclosure and the claims) may be examined to ascertain the nature of the invention. Where the words of the claims are plain and unambiguous and capable of only one interpretation by a person skilled in the art, recourse to the disclosure is unnecessary. This is not to say that the interpreter should not examine the disclosure. In my view, one should do so, but with caution. Recourse may be had to the disclosure for the purpose of confirming the interpretation arrived at from examining the claims alone or to disclose an ambiguity in the language of the claims that was not otherwise evident. However, the patentee cannot expand the monopoly specifically expressed in the claims by borrowing phrases from the disclosure and placing them into the language of the claims.

This threads the needle between the two approaches, though rightly favouring the SCC position that reference to the disclosure is permissible even when the claims are unambiguous. Nonetheless, Locke J was very careful to first read the words of the claims alone to determine whether they were ambiguous. He did have recourse to the specification in interpreting each disputed terms, but in almost every case, this was only after expressly concluding the claim alone was ambiguous. See eg his discussion of “audio/video signals,” concluding examination of the claim alone “certainly gives rise to enough ambiguity in this term to justify recourse to the disclosure in order to assist in understanding its scope” [49]. This implies that recourse to the disclosure, if not strictly impermissible, would not be “justified” absent the ambiguity. See similarly [58], [74], [81]. (The only exception was in considering the term “server,” where he adverted to the disclosure without expressly holding the claim was ambiguous on its own [66]).

Contrast Locke J’s analysis with Gauthier J’s approach in this case:

[41] As the issue of construction of the patent is to be reviewed on the correctness standard, I have performed my own analysis of the 693 Patent. I have thus considered, as proposed by Apotex, what the invention is by reading the full specification.

The first sentence is explicit that Gauthier J is performing her own analysis, which means the approach she takes would be also appropriate for a judge at first instance. The second sentence indicates that Gauthier J very first step in construing the claims is to read the disclosure, without a word as to whether there is any ambiguity in the claims themselves. She also stated (my emphasis) that

[48] It is trite law that a court will consider the disclosure when it construes the claims. I considered the disclosure as it may help to determine if the inventor gave a particular meaning to an expression or word in the claim by adopting a special lexicon. However, the disclosure cannot be used “to enlarge or contract the scope of the claim as written and thus understood” (Whirlpool at para. 52 in fine; see also Justice Rothstein’s comment in the seminal decision of Apotex Inc. v. Sanofi-Synthelabo Canada Inc., 2008 SCC 61 at para. 77 in fine, [2008] 3 S.C.R. 265).

This was not merely a statement of principle; Gauthier J’s analysis of the claims at hand began with a twelve paragraph discussion of the disclosure [49]-[60], before turning to the claims themselves.

The two approaches are not strictly inconsistent in principle, in that Locke J did acknowledge that it is permissible to look to the disclosure. Nonetheless, there is a striking contrast between Locke J’s claims-first approach and Gauthier J’s disclosure-first approach.

How can this tension be resolved? First, all of the cases agree on one fundamental principle: use of the disclosure is “improper to vary the scope or ambit of the claims,” and “improper if reference varies the scope of the claims”; “the patentee cannot expand the monopoly specifically expressed in the claims by borrowing phrases from the disclosure and placing them into the language of the claims”; “the disclosure cannot be used ‘to enlarge or contract the scope of the claim as written’”; and, from Sanofi [77] “Of course, it is not permissible to read the specification in order to construe the claims more narrowly or widely than the text will allow.” I am not aware of any case holding to the contrary.

In light of this principle, it is easy enough to see why recourse to the disclosure is unnecessary when the words of the claim are plain and unambiguous; it is unlikely to change anything. Even if reading the disclosure suggests a meaning that was inconsistent with the claims, the court would say, in effect, “I see what you should have said, but you didn’t say it, and I won’t redraft the claim for you.” If that’s right, whether one starts with the claims, or starts with the disclosure, should make no difference in the end. The point made by the SCC in Whirlpool is that there may be cases where the claims appear clear when read on their own, but the disclosure clarifies the true meaning. An example might be Catnic, where the word “vertical” in the claim might be taken to mean “90 degrees”, but reading the disclosure makes it apparent that it really means “sufficiently vertical to carry out the load bearing function.”* In that case, reading the disclosure changes our understanding of the claim, but does not read limitations from the disclosure into the claim. Rather the disclosure makes it apparent that the initial reading of the claim alone was wrong, because a word that appeared clear was in fact ambiguous. In such a case, it would be wrong to avoid recourse to the disclosure on the basis that the claims were unambiguous.

The really difficult case is when the claim says “up” and the disclosure defines “up” to mean “down.” I don’t have a ready answer for that case, except to say that would be a very poorly drafted patent. It would be better to address the such a case on its facts, in light of the underlying principles that claim defines the monopoly, but the skilled person reads the patent, rather than debating whether it is permissible or not to read the disclosure.

Finally, what about  the statement in CIALIS that "[t]he rules of patent construction preclude reference to the specification when the claims are clear," and also "as there was no ambiguity in the claims here, there could be no recourse to the specification" [43]? I acknowledge that these statements of principle are inconsistent with a disclosure-first approach, but there is no inconsistency on the facts, because in CIALIS the real problem was that the trial judge had indeed read in a limitation from the disclosure into the claim: see [40]. Thus the holding would have been the same on a disclosure-first approach. 

*This oversimplifies Catnic, where the claim construction at trial was not merely “a purely literal one derived from applying to it the kind of meticulous verbal analysis,” as suggested by the HL.

Monday, January 16, 2017

Methylphenidate Dosage Form Patent Valid and Infringed on the Facts

Janssen Inc v Actavis Pharma Company 2016 FC 1361 O’Reilly J
            2,264,852 / methylphenidate dosage form / CONCERTA / NOC

In this brief decision O’Reilly J granted Janssen’s application for an order prohibiting the Minister of Health from issuing an NOC to Actavis in respect of its generic version of CONCERTA, a drug used to threat ADHD [1]. Actavis’ invalidity and non-infringement arguments failed on the facts and on claim construction.

The active ingredient in CONCERTA is methylphenidate (“MP”), but the ‘852 patent does not cover MP itself, which was long used in the treatment of ADHD, particularly in the well-known drug Ritalin [7]. Rather, it covers a formulation which provides a “sustained-ascending dose over time,” for regulation of tolerance to MP. While Ritalin was widely prescribed, the original immediate release formulation had to be taken either two or three times a day, which led to compliance problems with school age children [8]. A subsequent slow-release formulation was puzzlingly ineffective, as it too worked only for a few hours. The insight which was the basis of the ‘852 patent is that the reason for the short duration of effectiveness, even for the slow release formulation, might be “acute tolerance,” where a patient becomes tolerant to a drug within a single dosing period [14]. This would explain the failure of the slow-release formulation; while the plasma concentration was stable over the dosing period, it became less effective because the patient developed tolerance over the same period. This hypothesis turned out to be correct [18]-[19]. This discovery led to the development of the ‘852 formulation, which provides a dosage that increases over time, so as to provide a stable response once balanced against the tolerance that would develop over the same period.

Actavis’ main invalidity attack was based on obviousness. Actavis argued that all the inventors had done was to confirm the hypothesis that the problem with slow-release Ritalin was acute tolerance to MP [44]. However, on the facts, while acute tolerance was one of the conceivable reasons for the problem, is was not at all obvious that it was actually the cause; indeed, most researchers at the time doubted that acute tolerance was the reason for the problems with slow-release Ritalin [47]. In light of this, the fact that it was easy to actually make a sustained-ascending dosage form is beside the point [48]. As was said long ago, in Canadian Gypsum [1931] Ex CR 180, 187, “[T]he inventive ingenuity necessary to support a valid patent may be found in the underlying idea, or in the practical application of that idea, or in both. It may happen that the idea or conception is a meritorious one, but that once suggested, its application is very simple,” but that is no bar to obtaining a patent.

On claim construction, Actavis argued that the phrase “sustained-ascending dose over time” meant “over an entire dosing period”. This was rejected by O’Reilly J, in favour of an interpretation that the dosage would have to rise for a sufficient duration to provide effective treatment over the dosage period [33]. This is different, given that the drug continues to be effective for at least a couple of hours after it stops releasing into the plasma [34].

While Actavis lost on claim construction, it had another non-infringement argument, namely that the release profile of its product was not good enough to make it effective at compensating for acute tolerance [57]. O’Reilly J rejected this argument on the facts, including the fact that Actavis’ product monograph confirmed both that the tablets will release MP at an ascending rate for 6 to 10 hours, and that the Actavis product was essentially equivalent to CONCERTA.

Friday, January 13, 2017

A Costs Cornucopia

Mediatube Corp v Bell Canada 2017 FC 6 Locke J
            2,339,447 / Internet Protocol Television / Fibe TV, FibreOp

In his decision, Locke J held that the plaintiff NorthVu’s ‘447 patent (Mediatube is the exclusive licensee), was valid but not infringed by Bell’s products. However, the infringement action fell apart halfway through the discovery process, if not sooner, with the result that the main thrust of the decision was more about allocation of costs rather than about patent infringement [7]. While no new principles of law were applied, the decision is important on costs simply because it is unusual to see so many requests for elevated costs considered, and several actually granted. This post focuses on a few of the more interesting costs issues. These turned generally on Rule 400(3) and particularly Rules 400(3)(i), which relates to conduct which tend to “unnecessarily lengthen the duration of the proceeding,” and (k) which relates to steps which are “improper, vexatious or unnecessary,” or “taken through negligence, mistake or excessive caution.” The overall message is that there will be costs consequences against a patentee for proceeding with a claim that it should have known was without merit.

Friday, January 6, 2017

No New Cases for the Week of 2 January

No new patent / NOC / data protection cases were released for the week of 2 January 2017.

Friday, December 30, 2016

No New Cases Last Week

Not very surprisingly, no new patent / NOC / data protection cases were released over the past week. I hope everyone at the Federal Courts had a good break, and will return ready to deal with all the interesting and difficult issues that patent law throws at us. Here's to 2017!

Tuesday, December 20, 2016

Sublingual Dosage Form Patent Valid but Not Infringed on the Facts

Meda AB v Pharmascience Inc 2016 FC 1362 Manson J
            2,629,988 / zolpidem / SUBLINOX / NOC

In this NOC proceeding, Meda’s ‘988 patent was held to be substantially valid, but not infringed by Pharmascience’s PMS-Zolpidem product. This result turned entirely on the facts, and no significant points of law were raised. The overbreadth discussion does provide an interesting example of the role of claim differentiation.

The ‘988 patent is a formulation patent, claiming zolpidem for the treatment of insomnia in a sublingual dosage form comprising an ordered mixture, in which the API is adhered to larger carrier particles, and a bio/mucoadhesive promoting agent [76]. (As I understand it, an “ordered mixture” means a homogeneous mixture, as opposed to a random mixture in which some degree of segregation may occur.

Validity was attacked on the basis of anticipation, obviousness, lack of utility and overbreadth [18]. The anticipation argument failed because the prior art relied on did not teach an ordered mixture or sublingual administration [134]. The patent is a combination patent, in the sense that all the elements were known in the prior art [77], and the question was whether it would have been obvious to combine them. On the facts, Manson J held that the combination was not obvious [154]. Pharmascience’s argument to the contrary was not helped by the fact that in a review article its own expert had described the ‘988 patent as “an unusual approach” and “very different from all the formulations that [he’d] read” [151]. The utility attack was based on the promise of bio/mucoadhesion. Manson J held that “[a]ll that is required is sufficient bio/mucoadhesion to achieve the promised rapid release and absorption” [176] and this promise was demonstrated by examples in the patent [178].

Pharmascience also attacked the patent on the basis of overbreadth. Specifically, Pharmascience argued that the claims were overbroad because it was necessary that the formulation (1) have the bio/mucoadhesive agent on the surface of carrier particles; and (2) be essentially free from water [157], and Claim 1 was invalid because it did not have the first limitation, and all the claims were invalid because none of them had the second limitation. Both limitations were, however, disclosed in the specification, and Meda responded that a POSITA reading the claims in light of the specification would understand those limitations to be implicit [162]. Manson J agreed that a skilled person reading the claim “in light of the specification as a whole, with a mind willing to understand, would know that the formulation would have to be essentially free from water to work” [168]. The attack based on the absence of that limitation therefore failed. However, Manson J held that it was not permissible to read limitation (1) as being implicit in Claim 1, because it was explicit in Claim 2 and following claims, and “the presumption against redundancy precludes this limitation from being implied into claim 1" [168]. Consequently, Claim 1 was invalid for overbreadth [168]. However, this did not substantially affect the strength of the patent as a whole, because Claim 2 was exactly the same as Claim 1 except that it did include this limitation. The interesting point is what would have happened if Claim 2 had omitted this limitation; it seems not unlikely that Manson J would have been willing to find it to implicit, as he did with the requirement of being free from water.

While the patent was held to be substantially valid, Manson J held that Pharmascience’s allegation of non-infringement was justified [195]. The reasoning on this point is not entirely clear, as the discussion was substantially redacted. It is nonetheless clear enough that the result turned on the facts.

Friday, December 16, 2016

No New Cases for the Last Two Weeks

No new patent / NOC / data protection cases have been released in the last couple of weeks.

Note that I generally only blog on substantive patent / pharma cases. If you want to keep abreast of all new Canadian decisions, including procedural decisions and copyright and trade-mark cases, I recommend subscribing to the Daily Intellectual Property News service from Alan Macek's IPPractice.

Thursday, December 1, 2016

Are Damages an Element of a Claim under Section 7 of the Trade-marks Act?

Excalibre Oil Tools Ltd v Advantage Products Inc 2016 FC 1279 Manson J
            2,264,467 / 2,373,734 / 2,386,026 / torque anchor

E Mishan & Sons, Inc v Supertek Canada Inc 2016 FC 986 Hughes J
            2,779,882 / Industrial Design 146,676 / expandable garden hose

Tuesday’s post provided the background to the threats claim brought under s 7(a) of the Trade-marks Act, and yesterday’s post discussed the safe harbour for purely informative communications. Today’s post discusses the proposition, agreed to by counsel in Supertek 2016 FC 986 [7] and affirmed by Hughes J [28], that “Damages are . . . an essential element in a claim under section 7(a) of the Trade-marks Act.” Manson J put it somewhat differently, and more accurately, in Excalibre: “It is settled law that evidence of actual or potential damage is a necessary element for finding liability under section 7" [286, my emphasis]. The difficulty with this proposition, particularly in Hughes J’s formulation, is that if resulting loss is an element of the tort, then the plaintiff is not entitled to an injunction to restrain false statements discrediting its wares, and perhaps not even its costs in the action, unless loss has already been suffered. This is a very strange proposition. Certainly, a plaintiff is not entitled to a monetary award unless it has proven its loss, but why should a plaintiff be helpless to prevent false statements from discrediting its wares simply because it had the good sense to act promptly? Surely it is better to prevent the loss from happening in the first place than to provide relief after the fact.

Wednesday, November 30, 2016

Informative v Threatening Letters

Excalibre Oil Tools Ltd v Advantage Products Inc 2016 FC 1279 Manson J
            2,264,467 / 2,373,734 / 2,386,026 / torque anchor

E Mishan & Sons, Inc v Supertek Canada Inc 2016 FC 986 Hughes J
            2,779,882 / Industrial Design 146,676 / expandable garden hose

Yesterday’s post described the unjustified threats action under s 7(a) of the Trade-marks Act, and discussed its rationale, which is to prevent a patentee from interfering with the business of a competitor by persuading end-users, who are not interested in being caught up in litigation, to abandon the competitor’s wares. In light of that rationale, I must doubt the validity of the distinction between cease and desist letters that are threatening and those that merely informative. On the authority of Cullen J’s decision in M&I Door Systems Ltd v Indoro Industrial Door Co Ltd (1989), 25 CPR (3d) 477 (FCTD), it is said that the latter may engage s 7(a), while the former do not. As Mason J explained in Excalibre v API:

[282] Informative letters set out a patentee’s rights and provide information that will enable the recipient to understand what may constitute infringement. Threatening letters contain explicit or veiled threats that the recipient will be sued if they do not change a particular course of conduct.

Manson J accepted this distinction [282], as did Hughes J in Supertek [10]-[11], but neither actually applied it to defeat the action. Both held on the facts that the communications in question were threatening, in Excalibre J because the letters contained explicit threats of litigation [284], and in Supertek because the defendants had “deliberately and skilfully conducted themselves so as to leave [the recipient] with the impression,” that it would be sued for patent infringement [27]. The only case I have found in which the court dismissed the claim for a remedy under s 7(a) because the communication, while false, was “more informative than threatening” is M&I Door Systems itself (523).

M&I Door Systems cited no authority for this distinction. Indeed, Cullen J did not cite any authority at all on the interpretation of s 7(a) – not even the leading case, S. & S. Industries Inc. v. Rowell [1966] SCR 419. And M&I Door Systems is very difficult to reconcile with S. & S. Industries. Cullen J gave two main reasons for tempering his response to the claim under s 7(a). One reason is that the patent is prima facie valid and “the patentee has the right to act on that basis” (523). This point was the appellant’s main contention in S. & S. Industries (426), and it was rejected. As Gill notes, Cullen J’s holding on this point is “[s]eemingly in direct contradiction to the Supreme Court’s pronouncement in S. & S. Industries”: A. Kelly Gill Balancing Necessary Monopolies and Free Competition: Threats of Patent Infringement and Trade Libel (1998) 14 CIPR 125, 132. Gill was of the view that M&I Door Systems imposed a desirable limitation on the scope of s 7(a); while I don't agree on the policy point, I do agree with his legal analysis that M&I Door Systems is inconsistent with S. & S. Industries. The other main point made by Cullen J is that if he had held the patent valid, he would have had “little or no difficulty” in holding that it was infringed (523). This seems ancillary to the point regarding the prima facie validity of the patent, as the only basis for distinguishing between a false statement relating to validity and a false statement relating to infringement is that the patent is prima facie valid, while the patentee bears the burden of proving infringement. In holding that the prima facie validity of the patent was irrelevant, the SCC in S. & S. Industries implicitly rejected this distinction. Section 7(a) itself refers only to a “false or misleading” statement, and makes no distinction as to the reason why the statement is false. A third consideration noted by Cullen J was that the president of the patentee corporation, who sent the letters in question, was honestly convinced that the defendant’s products were infringing (523). Again, this goes to the absence of malice, and is irrelevant under S. & S. Industries. On the whole, I must wonder whether S. & S. Industries was even cited to Cullen J. Section 7(a) was raised as a counterclaim in an action for infringement, and the discussion of the issue was one page in a 47 page decision, the remainder of which dealt with validity and infringement. Perhaps the litigation effort was similarly apportioned.

Nor can a safe harbour for purely informative statements be justified as balancing the rights of the patentee to enforce its patent against the rights of the competitor to be free of unjustified interference. Even without any safe harbour for purely informative statements, the patentee will only be liable for damages under s 7(a) if it makes false statements that cause damage to the competitor by wrongly discrediting its wares. Why should the patentee escape liability if it has couched its false statements in the form of information rather than threats? Such a distinction seems to reflect the mala fides basis for the action which was rejected by the SCC in S. & S. Industries. Moreover, it is a very fine distinction, which may appeal to lawyers, but is unlikely to impress the practical business people who receive these letters, and who, as the facts in Excalibre show, may well not choose not to take legal advice at all. This opens the door to a patentee with a patent it knows to be weak, to nonetheless effectively halt its competitor’s sales. 

It may be suggested that without some kind of safe habour s 7(a) would be hard on small patentees who are legitimately trying to protect their patent rights. But adding in a safe harbour of this kind will be equally hard on small rivals who are legitimately trying to market a product which is in fact non-infringing. As Spence J pointed out in S. & S. Industries [1966] SCR 419, 423, the most straightforward means for a patentee to enforce its rights is to sue the manufacturer and join end-users, in which case the patentee may be able to obtain an interlocutory injunction restraining the allegedly infringing sales, but only on giving an undertaking in damages:

The injunction having been granted only upon his undertaking to pay the damages incurred thereby should he fail, he proceeds at his own risk. There would seem to be no valid reason why rather than choosing that forthright course he should be permitted to proceed by threats against the purchasers from the alleged infringer without rendering himself liable for damages unless his mala fides could be proved.

When seeking an interlocutory injunction, a good faith and reasonable belief in its claim does not shield the patentee from giving an undertaking. The threatened action against and end-user achieves the same end as an interlocutory injunction, namely to halt the competitor's sales, and accordingly, the SCC held that a reasonable belief in the validity of the claim is not a shield against s 7(a) either. By the same token, a patentee seeking an interlocutory injunction cannot avoid giving an undertaking in damages by asking politely, and neither should that shield it from liability under s 7(a).

A stronger justification for a safe harbour of this type is that without some kind of safe harbour the patentee would adopt what the UK Law Commission, No 360, ¶ 124 has described as “a ‘sue now – talk later’ culture because once infringement proceedings are issued, the provisions no longer apply.” Whether that is an adequate justification, given that any such safe harbour is liable to be abused, is a question for another day.

Tuesday, November 29, 2016

No Malice Requirement in Unjustified Threats Claim

Excalibre Oil Tools Ltd v Advantage Products Inc 2016 FC 1279 Manson J
            2,264,467 / 2,373,734 / 2,386,026 / torque anchor

In Excalibre v API, Manson J held that the three patents asserted by Advantage Products Inc (API), were either invalid or not infringed. This holding turned on the facts, and no significant new legal issues were raised. Of more interest, Manson J also held that the Excalibre parties were entitled to damages pursuant to s 7(a) of the Trade-marks Act, because API had threatened to bring infringement actions against end-users of the allegedly infringing Excalibre product, and these threats had caused the end-users to avoid buying Excalibre’s product. While Mason J applied established law on this issue as well, his decision is nonetheless significant as there have been only a handful of cases dealing with this provision in the fifty years since the SCC in S. & S. Industries Inc. v. Rowell [1966] SCR 419, aff’g 44 CPR 260 (Ex Ct) held that mala fides is not an element of a claim under s 7(a). This issue is salient at present because of the concern that patent assertion entities may level unfounded threats against end-users: see the 2016 US FTC Study on Patent Assertion Entity Activity Ch 3. (Though in this case, API is an operating company, not a patent assertion entity.) As discussed in this post, Excalibre v API is a paradigmatic example of liability for wrongful threats under s 7(a), and as such it illustrates why the threats action, and the SCC holding that mala fides is not an element, are sound as a matter of policy. In subsequent posts I will suggest that it is not correct as a matter of law to distinguish between threats and communications which merely provide information, and that this distinction is also dubious as a matter of policy. I also doubt whether it is right to say that damages is an element of the claim under s 7(a). While both of these points were raised in Manson J’s decisions, neither was crucial to the outcome.

In oil production, when a downhole pump is used to pump oil to the surface, the pump creates a torque which can cause the tubing string above it to unscrew. A torque anchor is a cylindrical device that prevents this by anchoring the tubing string to the fixed wellbore casing. The anchor is designed to lock into place when rotated clockwise (the direction of torque produced by the pump), and to unlock for removal when rotated counter-clockwise [34]-[36]. Both Excalibre and API make and sell torque anchors. API alleged that Excalibre’s CTA Torque Anchor infringed the API patents. As noted, Manson J ultimately held fact the CTA Torque Anchor did not infringe any valid patent.

In early 2008 some users of Excalibre’s CTA Torque Anchors, in particular Husky Energy Inc and Bronco Energy Inc, received letters from API’s lawyer stating, inter alia, that API held patents for specific torque anchor designs [29], that the CTA Torque Anchor infringed those patents, and that Husky and Bronco would be sued for infringement unless they immediately stopped sourcing CTA Torque Anchors [52]. These letters had the desired effect. Evidence from Bronco’s COO was that Bronco stopped using the CTA Torque Anchor immediately after receiving the letter, without even getting an infringement opinion, because it was easier to switch to a competing product [83]-[85]. Husky’s lawyer testified that Husky was litigation averse, and it also decided to stop purchasing the CTA Torque Anchor, without obtaining an infringement opinion, again because it was easier to switch to a different product [87]-[88]. She also stated that “an offer of an indemnity would not have changed her mind because she did not want to enter into a situation where Husky would be vulnerable to litigation” [90].

This is a paradigmatic illustration of the problem that the threats action is intended to address. For any individual end-user, the value of the product is its incremental value over the best alternative, which may well be less than the cost and inconvenience of litigation exposure. The manufacturer’s interest in defending its product is much greater, because the value to the manufacturer reflects its sales to multiple end-users. The value to the manufacturer therefore more closely reflects the aggregates social value of the invention. This means that a threat directed to an end-user may be effective in inducing it to stop using the product, even when infringement and validity are questionable.

Paragraph 7(a) of the Trade-marks Act provides that:

No person shall make a false or misleading statement tending to discredit the business, goods or services of a competitor;

The common law action of trade libel, aka slander of title, would only lie if the statements were made with malice. It was not enough that the statements made were untrue; they also had to be made without reasonable grounds for believing they were true: S. & S. Industries Inc. v. Rowell [1966] SCR 419, 426-27. However, s 7(a) is based not on the common law, but on Article 10bis of the Paris Convention for the Protection of Industrial Property, and, as Manson J noted at [279], in S. & S. Industries the SCC held that under s 7(a) there is no requirement that the false statements be made maliciously or with knowledge of their falsity. Thus he held that

[280] In this case, because I find that that no version of the CTA Torque Anchor infringes any of the API Patents, it is clear that Goodwin’s letters to Husky and Bronco (i.e., the January 16, 2008 Husky Letter; the February 1, 2008 Husky Letter; the April 28, 2008 Husky Letter; and the May 16, 2008 Bronco Letter), sent on behalf of API, contained false and misleading statements.

For convenience I will refer to a claim made under s 7(a) as a “unjustified threats” action, as the threats must be unjustified in the sense of being false, in order to attract liability. Because s 7(a) is not based on the common law, and because malice is not an element, the common law terms referring to slander or libel are no longer appropriate. The Canadian action must be distinguished from the action under s 70 of the UK Patents Act, 1977, which is referred to as an action for “groundless threats”, or, in the recently introduced Bill, “unjustified threats,” also on the view that “Threats to sue for infringement are unjustified where they are made in respect of an invalid right or where there has been no infringement”: Unjustified Threats Bill Explanatory Notes, ¶ 1. Despite this commonality, the UK provisions, both existing and proposed, are an evolutionary reform based on the common law, and the option of a reform based on Article 10bis of the Paris Convention was specifically rejected: see the UK Law Commission, No 360, ¶ 144. The UK experience is undoubtedly helpful in understanding the issues (see generally the UK Law Commission project on unjustified threats), but UK law on this point is not helpful in interpreting the Canadian provisions.

The absence of a malice requirement is sometimes criticized on the basis that a balance must be struck between “protect[ing] competitors and their customers against unfair threats, while still giving effect to the patent holder’s right under the Patent Act to charge these customers with infringement,” and the requirement of malice strikes this balance because it “permits the patent holder to exercise and protect its patent monopoly in good faith, while society is protected against the abuses caused by false and malicious threats of infringement”: A. Kelly Gill Balancing Necessary Monopolies and Free Competition: Threats of Patent Infringement and Trade Libel (1998) 14 CIPR 125, 128, 126; and see the UK Law Commission, No 346, ¶ 1.21, saying “The law should enable rights holders to assert and defend their rights, but this must be balanced by curbs on abuse,” (though the Law Commission recommended a safe harbour, rather than a mala fides requirement, as will be discussed in tomorrow’s post).

I accept the need for this balance, but it strikes me that an appropriate balance is struck even without any requirement of mala fides. A patentee whose patent is certainly valid and infringed can tell infringers as much without fear of liability, because the truth of its assertion is an answer to any action for unjustified threats. If its case is weak, the patentee will be exposed to risk, but it is only right that a patentee with a weak case should be hesitant to disrupt the business of a rival, on grounds that may ultimately prove unfounded. While the patentee is entitled to asserts its legitimate rights, the defendant equally has the right to operate freely if it is not in fact violating the patentee’s rights. The threats action, without any malice requirement, provides a proportionate incentive: the weaker that patentee's case, the greater the its exposure. In the absence of a malice requirement, the dial of potential liability increases smoothly as the patentee’s case becomes weaker. In contrast, a requirement of malice imposes a sharp cut-off; a patentee with a 49% probability that its patent is valid and infringed will expect to be liable for half the loss it causes (it will be 100% liable in 49% of cases, and not liable at all in 51% of cases), whereas a patentee with a patent that is 51% likely to be valid and infringed, faces no liability at all, though there remains a substantial likelihood that its threats are in fact unjustified.

Put another way, threatening a rival’s customers with an infringement action has the same de facto effect as an interlocutory injunction against the rival itself, as the rival will be effectively prevented from selling the allegedly infringing goods, before validity and infringement are definitively established. A plaintiff seeking an interlocutory injunction will almost invariably be required to give an undertaking to compensate the defendant for any harm caused by the injunction. The plaintiff is not excused from giving such an undertaking simply because it has a reasonable belief that its claim is well-founded. Nor is it excused from satisfying the undertaking if it turns out, after trial, that the plaintiff’s action was reasonable, though it ultimately failed. The requirement to give an undertaking in damages does not stop plaintiffs from seeking an interlocutory injunctions; it just ensures that they are appropriately careful when doing so. In the absence of an undertaking in damages, the risk would lie entirely with the defendant, who might suffer a substantial loss even if it ultimately prevails. Patent rights are no different from any other rights in this respect, and a patentee should not be able to use threats to a customer to harm a rival without fear of repercussion, even if the patentee had reasonable grounds for believing its patent was valid and infringed.

Addendum: I should have noted that in S. & S. Industries Spence J relied expressly on the parallel with an interlocutory injunction in holding that mala fides was not required under s 7(a):

Moreover, the person seeking to defend his patent has a choice of immediately commencing an action for infringement and applying for an injunction to restrain the continuance of such prejudice to his patent rights, or of bringing action for damages against those who use, in their business, the wares manufactured by the alleged infringer. If he chooses the first alternative, he may join as parties defendants all who purchase from the alleged infringer to use in their business. The injunction having been granted only upon his undertaking to pay the damages incurred thereby should he fail, he proceeds at his own risk. There would seem to be no valid reason why rather than choosing that forthright course he should be permitted to proceed by threats against the purchasers from the alleged infringer without rendering himself liable for damages unless his mala fides could be proved.

That is, if mala fides were an element, the patentee could avoid the risk associated with an undertaking by making threats against end-users.

Thursday, November 24, 2016

It Is Not Possible to Contract out of the Priority Provisions of the Patent Act

SALT Canada Inc v Baker 2016 FC 830 Boswell J
            2,222,058

The main issue in SALT Canada v Baker was whether the FC had jurisdiction to order the patent register to be varied under s 52 to list SALT as the owner of the `058 patent, where determining SALT’s ownership turned on the interpretation of contracts assigning the patent rights to various parties. My earlier post on this case focused on the issue of the court’s jurisdiction. This post is a belated footnote, elaborating on a point I had addressed only in passing.

As part of his analysis of the Court’s jurisdiction, Boswell J emphasized that “Statutory rights in a patent are governed by the laws of the jurisdiction in which the patent exists,” no matter what court has jurisdiction over the dispute, and regardless of what law is applicable to the contract of assignment. “Therefore, no assignment or transfer can take place except in accordance with the laws of [the jurisdiction of the patent]” [30].

[31] Accordingly, nothing in the assignment agreements could have the effect of exempting them from the operation of section 51 of the Patent Act, which renders an unregistered assignment void against subsequent assignees. . . .

[32] The ultimate outcome of this case will thus need to take the Patent Act into account notwithstanding whatever provincial or foreign law may be applicable to the assignment agreements at issue. This will be so regardless of the forum that ultimately adjudicates this dispute, be it a provincial superior court in Canada or the Superior Court of the State of Georgia. . . .

I felt this point to be so clearly correct that all I said in my earlier post is that “This is certainly true.” Since then, I have seen some comments suggesting that it was a legal point of significance, so I thought I might elaborate.

The general principle is that the issue priority of rights affects third parties, and so cannot be varied by contract. A third party must know where to look to determine its rights. In particular, as Boswell J noted, s 51 renders an unregistered assignment void against subsequent assignees. This allows a party seeking to take an assignment from the current registered owner to look to the Canadian register to determine whether there are any prior rights that might impair its title. If the registration venue could be changed by contract, this would defeat the purpose of s 51. Therefore s 51 must apply regardless of the proper law of the contract, and by the same token it is not possible for the parties to an assignment of a Canadian patent to use a choice of law clause to displace the statutory priority provisions.

This is a long-established general principle of priorities. As the USSC explained in Harrison v. Sterry (1809) 5 Cranch 289, 298-99:

The law of the place where a contract is made is, generally speaking, the law of the contract; i. e. it is the law by which the contract is expounded. But the right of priority forms no part of the contract itself. It is extrinsic, and is rather a personal privilege dependent on the law of the place where the property lies, and where the court sits which is to decide the cause. . . . In this country, and in its courts, in a contest respecting property lying in this country, the United States are not deprived of that priority which the laws give them, by the circumstance that the contract was made in a foreign country, with a person resident abroad.

See similarly Gimli Auto Ltd. v. BDO Dunwoody Ltd., 1998 ABCA 154:

[9] Nor need one consider a choice-of-law clause in a lease, for the statute sets which law applies. Nor is this a suit between two parties to a contract. The whole point of the P.P.S.A. is to overrule certain contractual or property rights: Re Giffen, supra. The lessor and lessee could not, by contracting that the lease would be valid even if not registered, bind others. This is legislation on priorities: ibid.

The scholarly commentary wholly endorses this position. Cuming, Walsh & Wood, Perspnal Property Security Law (2d ed), 187-88 put is this way:

To what extent are the secured party and the debtor free to choose a different governing law than the law designated as applicable by the PPSA? Clearly, a contractual choice of law clause cannot bind third parties. It follows that contracting parties cannot displace the legal regime to which the PPSA refers issues relating to the validity, perfection and priority of security interests by selecting a different governing law in their contract. The proposition is a long-standing one, codified rather than introduced by the PPSA.”

See also the UNCITRAL Legislative Guide on Secured Transactions, Chapter 10, esp. para.13:

13. A corollary to recognizing party autonomy with respect to the personal obligations of the parties is that the conflict-of-laws rules applicable to the property aspects of secured transactions are matters that are outside the domain of freedom of contract. For example, the grantor and the secured creditor are normally not permitted to select the law applicable to priority, since this could not only affect the rights of third parties, but could also result in a priority contest between two competing security rights being subject to two different laws leading to opposite results.

Friday, November 11, 2016

What Did Whirlpool Decide?

Apotex Inc v Eli Lilly Canada Inc 2016 FCA 267 Pelletier JA: Boivin, Rennie JJA aff’g 2015 FC 875 Gleason J
            2,226,784 / tadalafil / CIALIS / NOC

This brief decision of FCA dealing with obviousness-type double patenting is important for its discussion of the FCA's view of precedent, both at the SCC level and its own. The decision first addresses the question of when the SCC should be taken to have settled a question of law. This topic is important not just for the issue at hand, but more broadly as the Federal Courts interprets and applies new Supreme Court precedent. The FCA also suggested that counsel might want to be more creative in thinking about how to approach obviousness-type double patenting. On both points, the FCA’s attitude bodes well for the future development of the law.

The 784 patent was attacked as being invalid for double patenting over patent 2,181,377 in two separate NOC proceedings, one involving Mylan and the other involving Apotex. The key issue in all the proceedings was the appropriate date for assessing obviousness-type double patenting: is it the claim date of the earlier patent, the claim date of the later patent, or the publication date of the later patent?

Mylan FC 2015 FC 17 was decided in Lilly’s favour in January 2015 (see here). The decision under appeal in this case, Apotex FC 2015 FC 875 was decided, also in Lilly’s favour, in July 2015 (see here). Mylan FC was affirmed by Mylan FCA 2016 FCA 119, which was issued in April of 2016. As discussed here, in Mylan FCA, the FCA rejected the latest date, namely the publication date of the later patent, and held that it did not need to decide between the two other possible dates, because the FC had held that on the facts, the 784 patent was not obvious over the 377 patent on either of the claim dates. Only a few days after Mylan FCA was issued, the appeal from Apotex FC was heard [8]. Pelletier JA remarked that “In the normal course, given that the double patenting issue is identical in both cases, this Court would have simply followed Mylan FCA and rejected Apotex’s double patenting argument on the basis that it had already decided this issue” [8]. But Apotex argued that Mylan FCA should not be followed because it was inconsistent with the SCC decision in Whirlpool 2000 SCC 67. The question therefore, was “What did Whirlpool Decide?” [28ff].

I won’t rehash the details of the Whirlpool decision, which was summarized by the FCA at [28]-[33]. Suffice it to say that Apotex made a plausible argument that the SCC in Whirlpool would have assessed double patenting as of the publication date of the later patent, if the issue had been before it [36-[37]. However, Whirlpool didn’t explicitly decide, or even address, the question of the appropriate date. The issue is whether the appropriate date should be considered settled by implication through exegesis of the SCC’s statements, or whether the question should be considered to have been left open.

Despite the appeal of Apotex’s argument, Pelletier JA rejected it (my emphasis):

[37] It is, in my view, improbable that Binnie J. would settle a significant point in the law of double patenting by implication and without addressing it directly. The care taken to justify the publication date of a patent as the date at which it is to be construed suggests that if Binnie J. intended to decide the issue of the comparison date of the claims of the patents in an obviousness double patenting suit, he would do so explicitly.

[38] Furthermore, the issue of the comparison date in double patenting cases had not arisen previously in the Supreme Court jurisprudence, nor in the works of the text book writers. It would be surprising, to say the least, if Binnie J. purported to deal with a novel question by implication. This is all the more so when one considers that the issue was there to be addressed if the Court chose to do so.

He therefore held that the question of the appropriate date remained open after Whirlpool [39].

In my view, Pelletier JA’s reasoning is both sound as a matter of policy and strongly supported by the SCC’s discussion in R v Henry 2005 SCC 76 [57]. In Henry the SCC reconsidered a number of its prior decisions, overruling some of them. The issue of the binding effect of SCC statements arose because R v Noël, 2002 SCC 67 was affirmed on its facts (Henry [49]) and the Attorney General of Ontario worried that some of the obiter would be seen as binding on trial courts. Binnie J, for the Court, that “ I do not think this ‘concern’ is plausible. The comment was neither part of the legal analysis nor a direction to trial courts. It was simply an observation by an experienced judge” [52]. Binnie J reviewed the law relating to the binding effect of its decisions, and summarized as follows (my emphasis):

[57] The issue in each case, to return to the Halsbury question, is what did the case decide? Beyond the ratio decidendi which, as the Earl of Halsbury L.C. pointed out, is generally rooted in the facts, the legal point decided by this Court may be as narrow as the jury instruction at issue in Sellars or as broad as the Oakes test. All obiter do not have, and are not intended to have, the same weight. The weight decreases as one moves from the dispositive ratio decidendi to a wider circle of analysis which is obviously intended for guidance and which should be accepted as authoritative. Beyond that, there will be commentary, examples or exposition that are intended to be helpful and may be found to be persuasive, but are certainly not “binding” in the sense the Sellars principle in its most exaggerated form would have it. The objective of the exercise is to promote certainty in the law, not to stifle its growth and creativity. The notion that each phrase in a judgment of this Court should be treated as if enacted in a statute is not supported by the cases and is inconsistent with the basic fundamental principle that the common law develops by experience.

This statement emphasizes that even direct statements by the SCC expressing a view on a point of law are not necessarily binding; it follows that inferences as to what the Court might have been thinking can never be binding. 

In his discussion, Binnie J acknowledged that in the 1970s the Court’s mandate shifted from error correction to development of the jurisprudence, and consequently, the Court’s work became more oriented to “the development of a general analytical framework which necessarily went beyond what was essential for the disposition of the particular case” [53]. While Binnie J noted that this is particularly true in the Charter context, there is no doubt that we have seen a similar shift in patent law as well. Binnie J acknowledged that this shift meant that some statements that are strictly dicta should nonetheless be considered to be effectively binding: “It would be a foolhardy advocate who dismissed Dickson C.J.’s classic formulation of proportionality in Oakes as mere obiter” [53]. Nonetheless, it is still true that “the common law develops by experience,” and much of that experience is gained at the trial and appellate levels. Binnie J cautioned that the lower courts should not be too ready to overly broaden what the SCC had decided, because:

the effect would be to deprive the legal system of much creative thought on the part of counsel and judges in other courts in continuing to examine the operation of legal principles in different and perhaps novel contexts, and to inhibit or skew the growth of the common law. This would be a consequence totally unforeseen and unintended by the Court that decided Sellars.[56]

The Supreme Court of Canada is the highest court in our system, and we like to think that it has some of the best judges, but very able judges are found at every level of court, and the Supreme Court justices are not omniscient oracles. A judge in the Federal Court or the Federal Court of Appeal, will have more insight into the proper disposition of a legal question that is immediately raised on the facts before her and fully argued by counsel, than can be found in the inferred intent of a Supreme Court judge. Binnie J’s assertion that it is not “plausible” that obiter statements by the SCC could be seen as effectively binding on lower courts, is, with due respect, clearly wrong, as we know well in patent law, but the remainder of his discussion is entirely compelling.

In summary, not only was the FCA in this case right to hold that the remarks in Whirlpool were not binding authority on the issue of the correct date for assessing obviousness-type double patenting, to have held otherwise would have been inconsistent with the SCC’s own guidance in R v Henry on the binding effect of SCC decisions.

Finally, on a point of considerable practical importance, Pelletier JA concluded with the following observation:

[40] I might add that the analysis in the Earlier Cases, in Mylan FCA, and in this case was driven by the fact that the parties chose to frame the issue in terms of the date for comparison of the claims of the patents in issue. Having conducted the analysis on the basis chosen by the parties, we should not be taken as having decided that this framework for analysis is the correct one. The fact that this issue has not arisen in this form in the past may be an indication that there may be other ways to approach it. Perhaps, the Court, having construed the claims of each of the patents with the assistance of the persons skilled in the art, simply compares the claims and decides whether the later claims are patentably distinct from the earlier claims on the basis of the insights which it has gained in the course of the construction of the patents. This appears to be what was done in [Comm’r of Patents v Hoechst [1964] SCR 49], and more recently in [Sanofi 2008 SCC 61]. This is not to argue that this approach is any more correct than the comparison date approach but rather that, going forward, parties should not feel that they are locked into the framework chosen by the parties in these cases.

This observation is of a piece with Pelletier JA’s discussion of Whirlpool. Adherence to precedent is important to the predictability which allows parties to plan in reliance on the law, but sound precedent cannot grow in a straightjacket imposed by the idiosyncracies of how particular cases were argued: to repeat Binnie J’s words, “The objective of the exercise is to promote certainty in the law, not to stifle its growth and creativity."

Wednesday, November 9, 2016

The Patentee, Not the Infringer, Elects an Accounting

Bayer Inc v Cobalt Pharmaceuticals Co 2016 FC 1192 Fothergill J
            2,382,426 / ethinylestradiol & drospirenone / YAZ YASMIN

After Fothergill J held in 2016 FC 1013 that Bayer’s 426 patent was valid and infringed by Apotex and Cobalt, he asked for submissions regarding Bayer’s entitlement to elect between damages and an accounting of profits [1]. Apotex made the “novel” argument that it, rather than Bayer, should be entitled to make the election, and that Bayer should be restricted to an accounting of profits [2]. The statutory basis for this argument was evidently that s 57(1) provides that in the court “may, on the application of the plaintiff or defendant, make such order as the court or judge sees fit. . .for and respecting inspection or account. . . .” The equitable argument was that Apotex had prevailed in the prior NOC proceeding [2], the implication being that its subsequent launch was justifiable, and so it should be subject to the more modest sanction of an accounting of its own profits. The insurmountable difficulty with the statutory argument, as pointed out by Fothergill J, is that pursuant to s 55(1) the successful patentee is statutorily entitled to damages, and the court has no discretion with respect to that remedy [4], [9]. The question then arises as to why s 57(1) specifies that the defendant may apply for an order. I suspect that this is targeted at the final phrase of the provision, which allows the court to make orders “generally, respecting the proceedings in the action.” Such general orders might be sought by either party.

Fothergill J’s analysis of whether Bayer should be allowed to elect between damages and an accounting was brief. He noted that “[t]he fact that a defendant has taken a business risk and has obtained authority to market an infringing product pursuant to the NOC Regulations will not deprive a successful plaintiff of an election between damages and profits ,” citing 2008 FC 825 [509]-[510] (Snider J) and 2009 FC 991 [655], [663] (Gauthier J).

As discussed here and here, there has been something of a debate as to whether a succcessful patentee will normally be permitted to elect an accounting unless there is some reason why that remedy should be denied, or, on the other hand, an accounting will be denied unless the plaintiff can show some positive reason why it should be granted. The more recent tendency seems to be towards generally allowing an election. Fothergill J’s conclusion was consistent with this tendency: “Given that Bayer is entitled to damages pursuant to s 55(1) of the Patent Act, and all parties agree that an accounting of profits may also be an appropriate remedy, I see no reason to deny Bayer an election between damages and profits” [11]. However, given that Apotex did not oppose Bayer’s entitlement to an accounting, but rather insisted on it, not too much can be read into this.